New York City FCN. Mercau 21' · N. Mercau 45' · Talles Magno 85'
3:1Selesai
Colorado RapidsD. Yapi 45'
90'⇄Pergantian · New York City FCA. O'Neill ⇄ J. Shore
85'GOLNew York City FCTalles Magno (M. Moralez)
82'⇄Pergantian · Colorado RapidsK. Rosenberry ⇄ M. Diop
82'⇄Pergantian · Colorado RapidsJ. Travis ⇄ M. Navarro
76'⇄Pergantian · New York City FCA. Ojeda ⇄ Raul Gustavo
69'⇄Pergantian · Colorado RapidsH. Ojediran ⇄ J. Atencio
63'⇄Pergantian · New York City FCK. Parks ⇄ Talles Magno
55'⇄Pergantian · Colorado RapidsA. Manyoma ⇄ D. Sealy
55'⇄Pergantian · Colorado RapidsW. Frederick ⇄ T. Ku-DiPietro
45'GOLColorado RapidsD. Yapi (Rafael Navarro)
45'GOLNew York City FCN. Mercau
42'▮Kartu kuning · Colorado RapidsDarren Yapi
39'▮Kartu kuning · New York City FCAiden O'Neill
31'▮Kartu kuning · New York City FCNicolás Fernández
21'GOLNew York City FCN. Mercau
8'▮Kartu kuning · Colorado RapidsHamzat Ojediran