90+5'▮Kartu kuning · New York Red BullsMohammed Sofo
86'⇄Pergantian · New York Red BullsA. Mehmeti ⇄ E. M. Choupo-Moting
86'⇄Pergantian · Atlanta United FCF. Picault ⇄ Sergio Santos
86'⇄Pergantian · Atlanta United FCM. Almiron ⇄ L. Brennan
82'GOLAtlanta United FCF. Picault (M. Almiron)
82'▮Kartu kuning · Atlanta United FCFafà Picault
80'⇄Pergantian · Atlanta United FCC. Sanchez ⇄ S. Alzate
80'⇄Pergantian · Atlanta United FCE. Baez ⇄ R. Hernandez
79'⇄Pergantian · New York Red BullsE. Forsberg ⇄ M. Sofo
79'⇄Pergantian · New York Red BullsC. Cowell ⇄ C. Harper
79'⇄Pergantian · New York Red BullsM. Dos Santos ⇄ J. Marshall-Rutty
71'⇄Pergantian · New York Red BullsM. Jimenez ⇄ J. Ruvalcaba
69'GOLAtlanta United FCT. Muyumba (A. Miranchuk)
68'⇄Pergantian · Atlanta United FCM. Edwards ⇄ S. Gregersen
48'▮Kartu kuning · Atlanta United FCTomás Jacob
6'GOLNew York Red BullsE. Forsberg (A. Mehmeti)
-5'▮Kartu kuning · Atlanta United FCElías Báez